Tractor and dry van trailer on a highway — Truck Guard Insurance blog
Owner Resources

Trucking Insurance Companies: How to Compare Carriers, Programs, and Brokers as an Owner-Operator

Comparing trucking insurance companies is mostly comparing four things that a price hides: whether the company wants your kind of operation, whether it makes the filings you need, how it handles claims, and what happens at renewal. Ask for those in writing from each company, program or broker before you decide on cost. This article uses no company names and ranks nothing. It explains what to compare and what to ask. Once you choose, switching trucking insurance without a cargo coverage gap covers the handoff.

What does “trucking insurance company” mean to an owner-operator?

Three different things, and they are easy to confuse. A company is the insurer that bears the risk and issues the policy. A program is a package of terms for a defined class of risk, such as new ventures, dump trucks or refrigerated carriers, usually offered through a managing agent and backed by one or more companies. An intermediary is the agent or broker who helps you buy. When something goes wrong, the company answers the claim, the program defines the terms, and the intermediary answers your calls. Knowing which role each name plays tells you whom to ask what.

The company
Bears the risk, issues the policy and pays or denies the claim.
The program
Sets the terms, forms and eligibility for one class of operation.
The intermediary
Helps you compare, applies, and handles filings and certificates.
Three roles, three different answers when something goes wrong. The diagram shows structure only and carries no amounts.

How is an agent different from a broker, or from buying direct?

The definitions vary by state, so use plain terms and ask. An independent agent or broker can usually place you with more than one company. A captive or exclusive agent sells one company’s products. Buying direct means dealing with the company itself, with no intermediary, which is simple when your risk fits and unhelpful when it does not. None of these is automatically better. What matters is how many markets the intermediary can reach for your class, how it is paid, and whether it will explain the differences between what it finds. Check the intermediary’s license with your state insurance department.

One more source of confusion: in trucking a freight broker arranges loads between shippers and carriers, which is a different business from insurance. The broker, dispatcher and factor article separates the freight roles.

What should you compare besides price?

Five things, each of which you can ask for in writing.

  1. Appetite. Does the company or program write your kind of operation, equipment and lane mix, and your authority age? A company that writes you reluctantly will price or non-renew accordingly.
  2. Filings. Will it issue the MCS-90 and the BMC-91 or BMC-91X for your authority? 49 CFR 387.313 requires endorsements, certificates and cancellation notices to be in the form FMCSA prescribes, and 49 CFR 387.7 requires continuous coverage with thirty-five days’ written notice of cancellation. 49 U.S.C. 13906 ties your registration to keeping that security in place. The BMC-91 and MCS-90 article covers what each filing does.
  3. Claims handling. Who takes the first call, how quickly, and whether adjusters understand trucking. Ask the intermediary what it has seen, and ask for the claims process in writing.
  4. Financial strength. The UIIA insurance packet, for example, asks that the insurers’ NAIC numbers and rating appear on the certificate, which shows the kind of information a customer may require. Ask which ratings the company holds.
  5. Terms at renewal. Ask how the program treats a claim, a driver change or a new unit at renewal, and what notice it gives of changes.

What will a company ask you for?

Expect a short list: your authority and DOT numbers and the date the authority began, a list of units with their values, a list of drivers with license information and records, the commodities and lanes, and current loss runs, which are the claims record of your prior policies. Get loss runs early. A new venture has none, and a new authority’s market is narrower, which the first-year article explains and the start-up cost article places in the larger budget.

Real-World Scenario: Consider a hypothetical owner-operator who collects three quotes and picks the lowest. One quote lists fewer commodities on the cargo form, another carries a higher deductible, and the lowest comes from a program that does not file the certificate a key broker requires. The savings disappear the first week, when the broker rejects the certificate. A one-page side-by-side of forms, filings and deductibles would have shown it before the choice was made.

What about captives and risk-sharing programs?

Some trucking programs are built around a group of operators sharing part of the risk, often called a captive or a risk retention arrangement. In general terms these can reward good safety records and they can also ask the member to share in results, which a conventional policy does not. They have their own eligibility, collateral and exit terms. If one is offered, ask to see those terms, ask how the program pays claims, and compare it to a conventional policy on the same coverage.

How do you read two quotes that look the same?

Line them up by coverage, not by total. For each quote, write down the liability limit and its form, the cargo limit and the commodity list, the physical damage deductible and what the covered auto includes, and any added coverages such as trailer interchange or general liability. Then write down the filings, the cancellation terms and the payment terms. Two quotes with the same total can differ on four or five of those lines, and the differences are where the cost of a claim sits.

Then ask the intermediary to explain every difference between the two. A good explanation is specific: this quote lists your commodity and that one does not, or this deductible is higher and the premium reflects it. A vague answer is a reason to ask again. The overview in what motor carrier insurance is is a useful reference for what each line should be.

What should you ask about claims handling specifically?

Ask how a claim is reported: a phone line, an app, or through the intermediary. Ask who the first contact is and whether that person handles trucking claims regularly. Ask what the company expects from you in the first day, such as photographs, a police report number and the load documents. And ask how the intermediary helps when a claim is slow or disputed. A company’s claims behavior is hard to see in a quote, but the answers reveal whether the process has been thought through. For the layout of the policy those claims will be paid under, the coverage overview shows how the main coverages are structured.

What questions should you ask every company or intermediary?

  • Which companies or programs can you place me with for my class of operation?
  • Which of these makes the MCS-90 and BMC-91X filings for my authority?
  • What does each form list as covered commodities, and what does it exclude?
  • How are claims reported and handled, and who is my contact?
  • What do you need from me to quote, and how long will it take?
  • How are you paid, and does that change across the options?

What should you do next?

Write down your operation in one page: equipment, commodities, lanes, drivers and authority date. Ask each source for the same five items in writing, and put them side by side. The overview in what motor carrier insurance is shows what each line of a quote should be. To have the comparison done for you across several markets, start a quote, or read about the agency behind this site first.

The bottom line

Comparing trucking insurance companies is mostly comparing four things that a price hides: whether the company wants your kind of operation, whether it makes the filings you need, how it handles claims, and what happens at renewal. Ask for those in writing from each company, program or broker before you decide on cost.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an insurance company, a program and a broker?

A company bears the risk and issues the policy. A program is a package of terms offered to a defined class of risk, often through a managing agent, and it may be backed by one or more companies. A broker or agent is the intermediary who helps you buy. Knowing which is which tells you who answers a claim and who answers a question.

Is an agent the same as a broker?

The words are used differently in different places, and the legal definitions are set by each state. In plain terms, an independent intermediary can usually offer coverage from several companies, while a captive or exclusive agent sells one company’s products. Ask any intermediary which companies it can place with and how it is paid, and check its license with the state.

Is a freight broker the same as an insurance broker?

No. A freight broker arranges the movement of goods between shippers and motor carriers. An insurance broker or agent arranges coverage. The words overlap, and the roles do not. The broker-and-dispatcher article on this site separates the freight roles, and an insurance intermediary is a separate licensed profession in your state.

What are loss runs and why will a company ask for them?

Loss runs are a company’s record of the claims on your prior policies. A new company asks for them because past claims are one of the clearest signals of future claims. Ask your current company or agent for current loss runs early, since a quote may be delayed or declined until they arrive.

How do I check that a company can make the filing I need?

Ask whether it files the MCS-90 endorsement and the BMC-91 or BMC-91X certificate, and whether it will do so for your authority. Federal rules require that forms be in the prescribed form and that the endorsement remain in effect until terminated on thirty-five days’ notice. A company that cannot make the filing cannot support your authority, whatever its price.

Should I pick the lowest quote?

Not on price alone. A low quote that omits a coverage, lists fewer commodities, carries a higher deductible or comes from a company that handles claims slowly can cost more than a higher one. Compare the forms, the filings and the claims process side by side, and ask the intermediary to explain every difference.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Truck Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing trucking coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. Nate places trucking risks through an agency that compares several markets and explains each market’s terms before an owner-operator chooses. Connect via the Truck Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Get a trucking insurance quote

Send the basics on your authority, equipment, commodity, and lane mix. We pull the panel of specialty trucking markets quoting your class today.