Two tractor-trailers on a highway — Truck Guard Insurance blog
Cost Guides

Workers’ Comp for Truck Drivers: Who Needs It, Owner-Operator Options, and What Drives the Cost

Workers’ comp for truck drivers is usually around $1,500-$2,500+ per $50,000 in payroll. That is a typical range, not a quote or a guarantee, and actual premiums depend on the operation: the state, the classification of the work, the number of drivers and the carrier’s loss history. The cost question comes second, though. The first question is who on your payroll is an employee, because that is what creates the need for the coverage.

The broader mechanics, including the state-fund states and the interstate rating problem, are in workers’ compensation for trucking payrolls explained, and this article does not repeat them. It is about who needs the coverage, what an owner-operator can do, and what moves the number.

Who needs workers’ comp for truck drivers?

Any motor carrier that has employees as drivers generally needs to look at it, and the state decides the details. The U.S. Department of Labor says that private-sector employees should contact their state workers’ compensation board, since the federal programs cover federal workers and certain other groups. So the rules that apply to your drivers are the rules of the state or states where they work, including when coverage is required and how many employees trigger it.

The Department of Labor describes the benefits of workers’ compensation programs as wage replacement, medical treatment and vocational rehabilitation. That is what a hurt driver is relying on, and a carrier with an uninsured employee injury has a larger problem than the claim itself.

Is an owner-operator an employee or an independent contractor?

That is the question that decides whether a leased owner-operator is on your policy, and it is not answered by what the lease calls the person. The IRS lists three kinds of evidence for the common-law test: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, and says the keys are to look at the entire relationship and consider the right to direct and control the worker. That is a tax test. States apply their own tests for workers’ compensation, and some are stricter. For a state example, see first-year owner-operator insurance in Georgia.

The federal safety rules use a different definition for a different purpose. In 49 CFR 390.5, “employee” includes an independent contractor while operating a commercial motor vehicle, so safety rules apply to the owner-operator driver. That does not decide workers’ compensation status. A carrier should expect three definitions, federal safety, tax and state comp, to give three separate answers.

Employee driver
On the carrier’s policy, and payroll is the basis of the premium.
Contractor driver
Handled by contract and the state’s test, with a separate option of their own.
Owner of the business
Included or excluded by an election where the state allows one.
Three people, three routes to the same question of who is covered. The diagram shows structure only and carries no amounts.

What are an owner-operator’s workers’ comp options?

There are a few, and none works everywhere. An owner-operator who runs under their own authority with no employees may have no workers’ compensation obligation at all, depending on the state. One who has employees, or who forms an entity, may be asked to decide about inclusion or exclusion of the owner on the business’s policy. Some states let an owner or officer elect to be covered or excluded; the rules for who can elect, and how, are set state by state, so ask the state board.

An owner-operator leased to a carrier may be covered by the carrier’s policy, may buy a separate policy, or may buy occupational accident insurance, a separate accident coverage written by contract that pays for the owner-operator’s own injuries. Describe it as an alternative, not as workers’ comp. It does not carry the statutory benefits or protections, and its wording varies. The lease rule at 49 CFR 376.12(j) requires the lease to say who is responsible for insurance other than the public liability the carrier must maintain, which is where a lessor can see what the carrier does and does not provide.

What drives the cost of workers’ comp for truck drivers?

The premium is built on payroll, which is why the range above is stated per $50,000 of it. Five things move the result.

  1. State. Each state sets its own system and rates, and some run their own funds.
  2. Classification. Drivers and dock or warehouse staff are classified separately, and the classification of each payroll dollar matters.
  3. Payroll size and mix. More payroll means more premium, and the split between drivers and others changes the blend.
  4. Loss history. A carrier with recent injury claims pays more than one without, and the effect lasts for years.
  5. Safety and return-to-work practices. Documented training and a plan for bringing an injured driver back are things underwriters look at.

For a new authority, the same pricing logic is explained in the first-year insurance article, and the wider set of cost factors is in what drives trucking insurance premiums.

How should a carrier handle leased owner-operators?

Carefully, and with the state’s test in hand. A lease that calls a driver an independent contractor is evidence, not a verdict. The factors that tend to matter are the ones the IRS names: how much the carrier controls the work, how much the driver’s business is separate from the carrier’s, and what the relationship looks like on paper and in practice. A carrier that dispatches tightly, supplies the equipment, sets the pay and controls the schedule is describing something closer to employment than a carrier that offers loads a contractor may refuse.

Ask your agent how the policy treats uninsured subcontractors at audit. Some policies charge for payroll paid to contractors who cannot show their own coverage, which means a carrier can pay for the exposure either way. Collecting a certificate of insurance from each contractor, and keeping it current, is a routine way to avoid surprises. The related question of bobtail and non-trucking coverage is covered in the non-trucking liability article.

What should an owner-operator ask the carrier they lease to?

Ask whether the carrier’s workers’ compensation covers you, and get the answer in writing. Ask what the lease says about insurance, since 49 CFR 376.12(j) requires the lease to specify who provides insurance other than the public liability coverage the carrier must maintain. Ask whether any charge-back for insurance is stated in the lease. And ask whether you are expected to carry occupational accident insurance, and if so, which policy. Those four answers tell you whether you are covered, covered at your own expense, or not covered at all.

How does the premium audit work?

Workers’ comp is billed on estimated payroll and then reconciled to actual payroll after the policy period. A carrier that grew, added drivers or began a new type of work during the year will see the premium move at audit. Keep payroll records by classification, and tell your agent about changes during the year. The workers’ compensation coverage page lays out how the coverage sits beside the rest of the program.

Real-World Scenario: Consider a hypothetical small fleet that starts the year with a handful of employee drivers and adds a yard worker in the summer. The policy was written on the first payroll estimate and the yard worker was never reported. At audit the new payroll and a different classification appear together, and the premium rises more than the owner expected, because the change was reported after the year ended, not when it happened.

What should you do next?

Sort your drivers into employees, contractors and owners, and for each contractor ask whether the state would agree. Then ask your agent to price the payroll by classification and to show the audit terms. For a carrier building a program from the beginning, what motor carrier insurance is explains where this coverage sits next to liability, cargo and physical damage, and general liability for trucking operations covers the exposures that fall outside both. When you are ready, start a quote and send your driver list with it.

The bottom line

Workers’ comp for truck drivers is priced on payroll, usually around $1,500-$2,500+ per $50,000 in payroll, and the first question is whether a driver is an employee, because that is what creates the need. An owner-operator’s own options depend on the state and the contract, so confirm them with the state workers’ compensation board before relying on any one of them.

Frequently asked questions

Is the $1,500-$2,500+ per $50,000 in payroll figure a quote?

No. It is a typical range from placement experience, not a quote and not a guarantee. Actual premiums depend on the operation: the state, the classification of the payroll, the carrier’s loss history and the number of drivers. A carrier should treat the range as a way to check whether a quote is in the neighborhood, then get the real figure from its own application.

Does a motor carrier have to cover owner-operators it leases?

It depends on whether the owner-operator is an independent contractor or an employee under the state’s test, and on the state’s workers’ compensation law. Calling someone a contractor in a lease does not settle it. The agency that decides is the state, so a carrier with leased drivers should ask the state board and its agent before assuming those drivers are outside the policy.

What is an ownership exclusion?

It is a way some states let an owner or officer of a business choose not to be covered by the business’s workers’ compensation policy, and inclusion is the opposite choice to be covered. Whether it exists for your business type, and the rules for electing it, vary by state. Ask the state board whether your entity can make the election and what it must file.

What is occupational accident insurance, and does it replace workers’ comp?

It is a separate accident coverage that some owner-operators buy to cover their own injuries, written by contract rather than by state statute. It is an alternative to describe, not a substitute to assume. It does not carry the statutory benefits or the legal protections that workers’ compensation does, so compare the policy wording before using it in place of comp.

Why did my workers’ comp premium change at audit?

Premium is set on estimated payroll and then reconciled to actual payroll after the policy year. If actual payroll or the classification of the work differs from the estimate, the premium moves. Keep payroll records by classification and tell the agent about new drivers and new operations during the year, not after the audit.

Who regulates workers’ compensation for a private trucking company?

The states. The U.S. Department of Labor says private-sector employees should contact their state workers’ compensation board, because its own programs cover federal workers and certain other groups. A carrier with drivers in several states has to consider each state’s law, which is why an interstate payroll takes more care than a single-state one.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Truck Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing trucking coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. Nate places workers’ compensation for motor carriers and sorts the employee-or-contractor question with each carrier before the policy is bound. Connect via the Truck Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Get a trucking insurance quote

Send the basics on your authority, equipment, commodity, and lane mix. We pull the panel of specialty trucking markets quoting your class today.