The state adopts the federal financial-responsibility part, then displaces it for this cohort
Rule 4.3.1 is the adoption, and it is a long one. It requires every motor carrier subject to the Commission’s jurisdiction and every private commercial carrier subject to its safety jurisdiction to operate in conformity with federal rules published in twenty-six numbered parts of Title 49 — a list that runs 107, 171, 172, 173, 177, 178, 180, 325, 350, 382, 383, 385, 386, 387, 388, 389, 390, 391, 392, 393, 394, 395, 396, 397, 398 and 399 — plus 40 CFR part 262.
Part 387 is on that list. And then Rule 4.3.4 takes it back out for precisely the operation this page is about: “Notwithstanding the provisions of Title 49 CFR part 387, die provisions of Rule 3.1, rather than of Title 49 CFR part 387, shall govern die filings and limits of insurance or other financial responsibility that relate to die intrastate for-hire transportation of passengers upon the public highways of West Virginia and the intrastate for-hire transportation of nonhazardous property upon the public highways of West Virginia.”
The same paragraph’s proviso sets out what stays federal, and it is the mirror image: Part 387 “shall govern the limits of insurance or other financial responsibility that relate to die intrastate and interstate transportation of hazardous property … and the interstate transportation of passengers and nonhazardous property … to die extent that such transportation is subject to financial responsibility and insurance regulation.” Hazardous property is federal on both sides of the state line. Non-hazardous property is state intrastate and federal interstate.
What Rule 3 then sets is a table, and for freight equipment carrying non-hazardous property it is three figures: $200,000 for bodily injuries to or death of one person, $600,000 for bodily injuries to or death of all persons injured or killed in any one accident, and $100,000 for loss or damage in any one accident to property of others, excluding cargo. The same row for hazardous property does not give numbers at all; it says “Those minimum levels specified in 49 CFR 387.9”.
For an operator this is a genuine two-regime problem rather than a curiosity, because most light-combination work is not confined to one side of a state line by design. The same truck, the same driver and the same trailer can be answering to a state schedule on Monday and a federal one on Tuesday, with nothing changing but the destination and the commodity. A program written to one of them will fail the other quietly.
It is also the reason a West Virginia intrastate figure should never be quoted as the operator’s limit without asking what else the operation does. The displacement is scoped by commerce and by commodity, and both of those are dispatch facts.
- Intrastate, for hire, non-hazardous property — the state schedule at Rule 3.2 governs.
- Intrastate or interstate, hazardous property — Part 387 governs, by the express proviso in Rule 4.3.4.
- Interstate, passengers or non-hazardous property — Part 387 governs, to the extent that transportation is subject to financial responsibility regulation.
- The safety adoption at Rule 4.3.1 is unaffected either way; only the filings and limits move.